← All posts

Recording client meetings: what FINRA, SEC, FCA, and ASIC actually require

A plain-English look at what FINRA, the SEC, the FCA, and ASIC actually require for client records and communications — and what they don't.

Romilton Sumawang
Romilton Sumawang
· 9 min read
  • #compliance
  • #recordkeeping
  • #regulation
  • #minutes

There’s a persistent myth among advisors that the regulators require you to record your client meetings. There’s an equal and opposite myth that recording is forbidden. Both are wrong, and the gap between them is where a lot of unnecessary anxiety lives.

What the major regulators actually require is narrower and more practical than either myth: keep durable, accurate records of your client communications and the advice you give, hold them for a set number of years, and be able to produce them. Whether you get there by recording audio, by writing contemporaneous notes, or by generating structured minutes is, in most cases, left to you.

This post walks through what FINRA, the SEC, the UK’s FCA, and Australia’s ASIC actually say — with citations to the primary sources — and then draws the honest line between “what the rules require” and “what a tool can do.” None of this is legal advice; verify against your own regulator and your firm’s policies before relying on it.

United States — two regimes, not one

The single most common mistake here is treating “the SEC” and “FINRA” as one rulebook that applies to everyone. They don’t apply to the same people, and the record-keeping rules differ accordingly.

Broker-dealers: FINRA Rule 4511 and SEC Rules 17a-3 / 17a-4

If you’re a broker-dealer or a registered representative, your books-and-records backbone is FINRA Rule 4511 (“General Requirements”). It requires firms to make and preserve books and records as required under FINRA rules and the Securities Exchange Act, and to preserve them in a format that complies with Exchange Act Rule 17a-4. For records that don’t have their own specified retention period, Rule 4511(b) sets a default of at least six years. (FINRA Rule 4511)

Underneath that sit the SEC’s Exchange Act rules: Rule 17a-3 (the records a broker-dealer must make) and Rule 17a-4 (how long they must be preserved and in what form). The SEC amended Rule 17a-4 on October 12, 2022 to modernize the electronic-records requirements — including allowing an “electronic recordkeeping system” as an alternative to the older write-once/WORM approach. (FINRA — Books and Records)

What’s covered: communications relating to the firm’s business, account records, order and trade records, and similar. What’s notably not mandated: audio-recording every in-person client meeting. The obligation is to preserve the records, not to capture a recording of the conversation that produced them.

Registered investment advisers: Advisers Act Rule 204-2

If you’re an RIA, FINRA’s rulebook isn’t yours. Your books-and-records rule is Rule 204-2 under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 (17 CFR § 275.204-2). It requires advisers to make and keep records relating to their advisory business — including communications with clients and records bearing on recommendations and advice — and to retain them for at least five years from the end of the fiscal year of the last entry, with the first two years in an easily accessible place. Its scope expressly reaches business-related electronic communications. (17 CFR § 275.204-2 — Cornell LII)

Again: the rule is about keeping faithful records of advice and communications. It does not tell you that you must record the meeting.

And Reg BI sits alongside all of this

Regulation Best Interest (broker-dealers, compliance date June 30, 2020) is a conduct standard, not a record-keeping rule — but its Care, Disclosure, and Compliance obligations all assume you can substantiate what you recommended and why. RIAs are held to the parallel fiduciary duty the SEC reaffirmed in the same 2019 rulemaking. (SEC press release 2019-89 · FINRA — Regulation Best Interest) Neither requires audio. Both are easier to live up to when you have an accurate contemporaneous record. If you’re a financial advisor, that’s the practical workflow behind all of this — a Reg BI-friendly way to document client meetings without sending the conversation to anyone’s cloud.

United Kingdom — FCA SYSC 10A

The UK is the one place where “recording” is closest to an actual requirement — and even here it’s narrower than it sounds.

SYSC 10A of the FCA Handbook (“Recording telephone conversations and electronic communications”) requires in-scope firms to take all reasonable steps to record telephone conversations and keep copies of electronic communications that relate to activities in financial instruments. Firms must also take reasonable steps to stop staff from conducting that business on private equipment the firm can’t capture, must inform clients that conversations are being recorded before providing services, and must retain the records (generally five years, extendable on request by the FCA). (FCA Handbook — SYSC 10A)

Two important limits. First, SYSC 10A is about telephone and electronic communications connected to financial-instrument business — not a blanket mandate to record every in-person meeting. Second, certain firms dealing mainly with retail clients can rely on an exemption that lets them keep written notes or minutes of relevant conversations instead of audio. In other words, even in the jurisdiction with the strongest recording rule, a faithful written record is an accepted way to meet the obligation for many firms.

Australia — ASIC, RG 175, and the records-of-advice regime

Australia takes the “keep the record” approach rather than the “record the audio” approach.

When you give personal advice to a retail client, you must keep records demonstrating that you acted in the client’s best interests and that the advice was appropriate — the information you relied on, the advice given, and your reasoning. ASIC’s guidance lives in Regulatory Guide 175 (“Licensing: Financial product advisers — Conduct and disclosure”), which interprets the relevant conduct and disclosure obligations in Part 7.7 and Division 2 of Part 7.7A of the Corporations Act. (ASIC RG 175)

The specific record-keeping obligations were updated recently: ASIC’s Corporations (Record-Keeping Requirements for Australian Financial Services Licensees when Giving Personal Advice) Instrument 2024/508 took effect on 23 September 2024, replacing the expired Class Order 14/923. Records of personal advice to retail clients must generally be kept for at least seven years and be accessible throughout. (ASIC — Records of Advice FAQs)

Nothing in RG 175 requires you to audio-record the advice conversation. It requires you to be able to evidence what you advised and why.

The pattern across all four

Lay the regimes side by side and the same shape appears:

RegulatorCore record-keeping anchorTypical retentionMandates recording the meeting?
FINRA (US, broker-dealers)Rule 4511 → SEC 17a-3 / 17a-4≥ 6 years (default)No — preserve records, not audio
SEC (US, RIAs)Advisers Act Rule 204-2≥ 5 yearsNo
FCA (UK)SYSC 10A~5 yearsPhone/electronic comms only; written notes accepted for some firms
ASIC (Australia)RG 175 / Instrument 2024/508≥ 7 yearsNo

The throughline: regulators want a faithful, durable, retrievable record of your client communications and advice. Audio recording is one way to get there, and in the UK it’s the default for certain phone/electronic business — but across the board, a well-structured contemporaneous record of what was discussed and decided is the thing the rules are actually after.

Where a tool fits — and where it doesn’t

This is the part that’s easy to overclaim, so let’s be precise.

A note-taking tool cannot make you compliant. It can’t read your jurisdiction’s consent rules, it doesn’t know your firm’s retention schedule, and it certainly can’t certify anything. SumaFlow Minutes makes none of those claims. What an on-device minutes tool can do is help with the practical task underneath every one of these regimes: turning a client meeting into a faithful, structured, editable record — and doing it without uploading a confidential conversation to anyone else’s cloud.

SumaFlow Minutes records the meeting, transcribes it, and generates structured minutes entirely on your phone. The minutes are produced under a strict “never invent” rule, so the record reflects what was actually said rather than a model’s embellishment. (That word “faithful” is carrying a lot of weight, and it deserves a precise definition — here’s what it has to mean.) The audio, transcript, and minutes are stored encrypted on the device, and nothing leaves it unless you export a single meeting yourself. That keeps the record-keeping half of your obligations easier to satisfy while keeping client confidentiality intact — which is the whole reason advisors hesitate to record in the first place.

Retention and retrieval are the half of recordkeeping that bites years later, and that’s where SumaFlow Minutes Pro earns its place — same on-device architecture, just power tools over a long archive:

  • On-device full-text search to find any past record in seconds.
  • Batch export and merge to assemble the records you may need to produce.
  • Encrypted device-migration backup so a new phone never costs you a record — and never routes one through the cloud to move it.
  • Audio playback with transcript sync to review exactly what was said.

To be clear about the limits, since this is the post where overclaiming is tempting: none of this certifies anything. Pro doesn’t make a record “compliant”; it makes records easier to keep, find, and produce — which is your job, not the tool’s. It’s additive, never locks the meetings you already have, and is bought in the app via Google Play with no account and no payment data reaching us. Here’s how that paid tier stays honest, and the full Free vs SumaFlow Minutes Pro comparison if you want it.

What stays with you: deciding whether and how the rules apply to you, getting consent to record where it’s required, setting your retention period, and treating any exported copy under your firm’s controls. The tool produces the record. Meeting your obligations remains your job — exactly as the regulators intend.

Private AI meeting minutes — on-device, no cloud. Get SumaFlow Minutes free on Android.

Primary sources

This article describes what regulations require; it is not legal advice and does not claim that SumaFlow Minutes is certified or compliant under any of these regimes. Verify against the primary sources and your own firm’s policies.